Five Questions That Decide What Sterling Hedging Really Costs
Photo: National Bank of Australasia (note), Heritage Auctions (image), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Currency hedging occupies an odd position in UK portfolio construction. It is widely recommended, frequently implemented, and rarely costed with the same rigour as an active management fee. Yet the cost is not small, and it is not constant. It moves with the interest rate differential between sterling and the currency in question, with the tenor of the hedge, and with the volatility that determines what the counterparty charges for the residual risk it carries.
What follows is not an argument for or against hedging. It is a framework of five questions that should be answered before a hedge ratio is set, and revisited whenever the rate environment shifts.
Question one: what is the hedge ratio actually protecting?
A hedge ratio is usually quoted as a single number for a whole portfolio, which conceals a decision about what risk is being managed. Hedging a global equity allocation back to sterling reduces the volatility of the sterling return, but it does not reduce the volatility of the underlying assets. It converts two sources of risk into one, and in doing so removes a partial natural offset.
The question to ask is whether the objective is to stabilise the reported sterling value, to reduce drawdown in a funding-ratio sense, or to remove a currency exposure the investor has no view on. Each points to a different ratio. A pension scheme with sterling liabilities and a long horizon may rationally hedge a high proportion of developed-market bond exposure and rather less of equity. A fund with a short horizon and a published sterling benchmark may reasonably hedge more. Blanket 50% hedging is a default, not an answer.
Question two: what is the roll paying or costing?
A hedged share class or a rolling forward programme is a series of short-dated contracts renewed as they expire. The return from that roll is driven almost entirely by the interest rate differential between the two currencies, and it is the single largest determinant of hedging cost over a multi-year horizon.
Where the foreign currency's short rates sit above sterling's, hedging that exposure back to sterling has historically carried a cost roughly equivalent to the differential. Where they sit below, the hedge has been a modest source of return. This is not a market inefficiency; it is covered interest parity doing its work, and it means that a hedge implemented in one rate environment can behave very differently in another.
With the sterling easing cycle having progressed and rate expectations in the United States and the euro area diverging, the sign and scale of the roll differ materially by currency pair. An investor running a single blended hedge across a global book is therefore running a blended and largely unexamined carry position.
Question three: how does volatility show up in the price?
The roll is the visible cost. The invisible one is the price the counterparty charges for bearing the risk that the hedge itself moves against it before it is rolled.
This appears in bid-offer spreads on forwards, in the cost of resetting collateral, and in the margin required on any programme run through an executing broker. In calm markets these are basis points. In stressed markets they widen sharply, and the widening tends to coincide with the moment a portfolio most wants to adjust its hedge. Stress-testing the hedging programme for a 2022-style dislocation, when gilt collateral calls became the binding constraint for liability-driven strategies, is a worthwhile exercise for any investor running large forward books.
Question four: is the benchmark already hedged?
This is the most common and most expensive oversight in UK fund selection. A currency-hedged share class sitting inside a portfolio measured against an unhedged benchmark — or the reverse — creates a tracking error that is neither intended nor compensated.
The check is straightforward but must be done at both levels. Establish whether the fund's stated benchmark is hedged, whether the share class you hold is hedged, and whether the hedge is applied at share class level or inside the strategy. Then confirm that the fee you are paying for the hedged share class reflects only the hedge and not a duplicate. Layered hedging is not uncommon in multi-manager structures, and it is rarely spotted until performance diverges.
Question five: who is taking the counterparty risk?
A rolling forward programme is an unsecured exposure to a bank until collateral arrangements are considered. Under standard credit support annexes, exposure is collateralised daily above a threshold, which reduces but does not eliminate risk.
Investors should know the counterparty, the threshold, the eligible collateral and the frequency of valuation. Where hedging is delegated to a fund manager, the same questions apply to the manager's programme, and the answers should be available on request rather than reconstructed after a stress event. Concentration matters too: a single counterparty for a large programme is efficient until it is not.
A note on the 2026 backdrop
The practical message for the current year is that hedging is not a fixed cost to be assumed at the outset of a mandate. Rate differentials have narrowed in some pairs and widened in others, and the divergence between central bank paths has made the roll a genuine active variable rather than a background constant.
That argues for three disciplines. Review the hedge ratio at least annually against the stated objective, not against last year's default. Report the roll cost separately from the underlying asset return so that it is visible rather than absorbed. And stress the programme for a collateral event, because the cost of hedging in a calm quarter is a poor guide to its cost in an unsettled one.
Risk reduction is worth paying for. It should not be paid for twice, and it should never be paid for without knowing the price.